A Writer's Edge

WRITING, EDITING, GHOSTWRITING

My Photo
Name: Georganna Hancock
Location: San Diego, California, United States

About.....Blog.....Writing Help.....Editing.....Writing Services.....Resume.....ID & Credits.....Subscribe


Search the web Search A Writer's Edge

Friday, July 20, 2007

Poetic Rhetoric Discourages Readers

Poetic tastes and audiences differIn a forum recently someone asked, "How do you judge poetry?" I sensed an explosive topic immediately, probably posted by a frustrated poet . Frustrated at not getting work published, not winning a contest and most likely not appreciating someone else's poem that won a contest. I didn't step into the fray, feeling that critiquing poetry is even more intensely personal than writing a book review. As Nancy Breen points out in her post in Poetic Asides:

No wonder it's so hard to attract readers to poetry. Once they sense that one way or another they're going to get dragged into an intellectual throw-down ("Ewww, you read that guy?" "Oh, please--poetry that doesn't rhyme is just crap!"), they run for the hills.
You don't have to defend your work, style or taste if others don't appreciate it--you probably don't like theirs, either. Let's de-escalate the rhetoric that surrounds poetry and get on with the enjoyment!

Labels:

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

2 Comments:

Blogger Wendell said...

Yes, exactly! We've learned to be okay with widely difference versions of "good music" (country, jazz, operatic, etc.). Why can't we accept that tastes differ in poetry?

I know how I write, though not what the style is called. I know others who write the same way - I read and enjoy and learn from them. I know things that make my writing "better" according to the logic of this style or school or beat or whatever. I try lot of things that make my writing "worse" (again, according to my own tastes).

But what I don't do - don't ever want to do - is compete.

4:38 PM  
Blogger Myth said...

It is difficult to critique poetry, because I am not a poet. Except angst filled crap I wrote when I was a teenager. However, much like with art, I know what I like when it comes to a poem. It is very much like a persons' taste in music, where certain songs just hit a chord with you. Therefore, something can be structually sound and a fine poem, but just does not strike me. However, I can appriciate the skill and effort that went into it and I certainly have a few classic favorites.

12:08 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home



Powered by FeedBlitz

<--/div>
NEWEST LINKS

Yahoo! Answers
About Us
OEDB
Blogged
Bloggapedia

RECIPROCITY

Psybertron
Bread and Roses
Shrinking Violet
Damian's Blog
Thought Patterns
Outpost Mavarin
Still Unhinged
Twerpette
Ballpoint Wren
The Writing Show
Media by Sistrunk
River Tyde
Mark Leslie's Blog
At Home, Writing
Pop Culture Casualty
Kate blogs about writing
Dangerous Bill's
Incurable Disease ...
Education by Sistrunk
Messages from Mavarin
Write Outta My Mind!
Writer's Words/Ed.'s Eye
The Writing Life
I Breathe; Therefore...
the way I see it
Horizons Past
Web Writers Cafe
Spirit Moved Me Again
The Hermit
Ain't Nothin' Like ...
The Write Life
Coffee and Critique
Writing Thoughts
Elvis, Elves and ...
A Newbie's Guide ...
Leftbrainwrite
Writer's Perspective
Words on The Page
The Opinions
Yunar's Online Venture
worlds that never were
Web Writers Cafe
Confessions ... Writer
Howling in Silence
bluemango
The Writer's Perspective
Circuit Mouse
Blue Ribbon Bloggers
Speedcat Hollydale
Paradise Valley 2...
1writeway
The Night Country
Beth and Writing
B.Burcroff
The Freelance Zone
Struggling Writer
Jack Mandora
Editor Unleashed
Midwest Book Review
Day by Day Writer
Spunk on a Stick

Original Blue Ribbon Blogger Blogcritics: news and reviews

Performancing Metrics

Lockergnome

Visit LAMPhost.NET for great web hosting

LAMPhost.net

Powered by Blogger