Quality is the key factor in prolonging the preference for traditionally published over self published efforts. I'm referring to the quality of writing, editing, production, distribution and policy. This came to mind as I read the first book I knew was self-published, and by BookSurge no less. I was especially interested in the quality of the physical object and the appearance of the printed pages. The book proved a pleasant surprise. Nice layout, decent paper, great cover. From the quirky font used for page numbers and the plethora of illustrations, I suspect it was printed from .PDF files, probably prepared by the author.
All too often, self-published books look like they were printed on paper recycled from public toilets. Other problems include spacing issues between lines, letters, words and text on the pages (margins). Blah covers predominated the ones I've seen. Writing difficulties suggest a lack of professional editing. In fact, a lack of professionalism in most aspects marks self-publishing efforts, and this is what traditional publishing
usually brings to the effort. Or maybe I should say, the professional touches
used to be apparent. This winter I received a book for review from a Random House imprint. I had to check to see if they used "green" paper, but no such notice appeared. The paper was grey!

Self-publishing authors cannot be expected to be experts in the intricacies of sales to bookstores and distribution of products, as well as commandeering advertising and marketing campaigns. A focus on producing high quality writing is enough for a one career. Publishing books is a complex industry that interfaces with and spawns other types of employment, e.g., printing being the most apparent. The traditional book industry's business model may be flawed, but the dinosaur lumbers on. Selling books to the public is yet another specialized type of work.
It is the lack of quality in all aspects, beginning with missing gatekeepers, that continues the bias against representing, reviewing, listing, and carrying self-published material. Many DIYers wind up becoming small publishers after learning all the elements involved with a first book (and often making many mistakes). When the inequity in quality reaches a balance (no matter how achieved), the disparity and disdain will automatically disappear. But no one person can do it all and well.
Labels: authors, books